The Russian Orthodox church, even as it struggles to renew the ancient faith, has entered a joint venture with California businessmen to bottle and sell natural waters under the rubric Saint Springs Water Company. Until recently this sector has been regarded as the engine of all developed economies. Orthodox Hasids and brooding neo-Nazis have both turned to rock music to get their traditional messages out to the new generation, while fundamentalists plot virtual conspiracies on the Internet. Barber offers no clear answer, but I think that McWorld offers the best opportunity for this. Their aim is but tribes, many of them at war with one another. The decline of American manufacturing in traditional domains like steel and automobiles has thus been closely associated with a putative erosion in world economic leadership.

I think we should tap oil reserves in the US if “all hell breaks lose” and we are in a global war that makes us decouple from the rest of the world. Domestically, most nation-states have struck the balance that is the meaning of democratic capitalism. Barber states that even though the US is losing the deficit war in terms of manufacturing jobs, and possibly soft ware jobs, we are winning the war in terms of new service jobs of the 21st century because like always we create an industry out of thin air and run with it. The modern democratic state is legitimated by the priority of the public over the private, where public goods trump private interests and the commonweal takes precedence over individual fortunes. Let us do what producers and consumers do: In late-nineteenth-century America, when the federal government was markedly weaker than it is today, social relations looked rather like global relations do today. Lastly, he doesn’t reckon with the fact that the second age of globalization has seen more people lifted out of poverty, largely through the lifting of economic, informational, and technological barriers between and within nations, than any other point in human history.

Apr 05, Rhys rated it really liked it Shelves: But no one is a citizen.

Jihad vs. McWorld

Despotic nations o er no such solvent to nationality and religion, which are strengthened in ways solvent to nationality and religion, which are strengthened in ways obstructive to modernization and democratization.

Nevertheless, the citations are excellent and provided further fodder for me to Google, since I was more aware of some but not all of the referenced events when they occurred when I was in high school. That middle section on Jihad though, just feels really poorly supported, and uninformed about some of the things he derides.


The rub, then, is to extend structures like those that exist at home to the international sphere. Instead, ‘Jihad’ for Barber is more concerned with tribalistic, exclusivist, nationalistic identities that emerge as a reaction to an all-encompassing, soulless and faceless imperialist economic-system that destroys culture worldwide in order to create homogeneity for saleability; a world to be dominated by hedonistic consumerism driven by markets that is fu I read this book within 24 hours.

Interdependence is not some foreign adversary against which citizens need to muster resistance. More dramatic even than in India, is the strange interplay of Jihad and McWorld in the remnants of Yugoslavia.

Terrorists, then, cannot themselves be the object of democratic mcword. Thus the ancient war cry of old and new capitalists alike: Potential agricultural behemoths like Russia and India sometimes seem hard-pressed to feed themselves: When America nally turns from its mythic independence and acknowledges the real world of interdependence, it will face an irony it helped create: Their deeds are unspeakable, and their purposes can be neither rationalized nor negotiated.

This is perhaps why majorities in all but a handful of ex-Soviet lands have been busy reelecting former Communist o jibad usually wearing new party labels and carrying new ideological doctrines to their new democratic legislatures. I underscore the importance of these new market hyperrealities here for two reasons: Before it began to trade in the international currency of McWorld that made it the global merchandiser, America had invented a simpler story about itself.

Analysis of Jihad vs. McWorld Article Written by Benjamin Barber – Book Report/Review Example

Perhaps that is too hyperbolic, but perhaps not, either. Outlaws prospered in the suites as well as in the streets. Long-lunch traditions obstruct the development of fast-food franchises and successful fast-food franchises inevitably undermine Mediterranean home-at-noon-fordinner rituals—whether intentionally or not hardly matters.

jihad vs mcworld thesis statement

Their political ambitions may not be politically motivated and their cultural ambitions may not be the product of cultural animus, but this only makes such ambitions the more irresponsible and culturally subversive. Participation in the Lives of Stagement Youth. A subtle warning against stereotyping or an unsubtle example of it?


On the global plane today, the historical symmetry that paired democracy and capitalism has gone missing.

Analysis of Jihad vs. McWorld Article Written by Benjamin Barber Book Report/Review

We say, in this world there is sickness, war and death. They are not even particularly antiAmerican; rather, they suspect that what Americans understand as prudent unilateralism is really a form of arrogant imperialism, that what Americans take to be a kind of cynical aloofness is really selfabsorbed isolationism, and that what Americans think of as pragmatic alliances with tyrannical rulers in Islamic nations such as Saudi Arabia and Pakistan are really a betrayal of the democratic principles to which Americans claim to subscribe.

Barber is either too old or too reflexively negative to see this positive potential within McWorld.

Jun 23, Michael rated it did not like it. Of the twenty- ve largest advertising companies, fteen are American. They are made possible by cooperation and they command interdependence. The nation-state would play a diminished role, and sovereignty would lose some of its political potency.

Jihad vs. McWorld by Benjamin R. Barber

The international institutions available to those who wish to make interdependence a tool of democracy and comity are far and few between. As he states, communist China, Singapore, and Vietnam are all autocratic regimes that have a thriving capitalistic system.

jihad vs mcworld thesis statement

Much of his take on globalism is acceptable, though he contradicts himself especially in the crappy intro by alternately pointing out its transnati I really had high hopes for this one. The chapters deals with the dominance of media in international markets, thus making the American ideal, the global ideal.

Was America ever really a safe haven in the tainted streams of world history? And even where multinational companies claim to be interested exclusively in production and consumption gures, increasingly they can maximize vw gures only by intervening actively in the very social, cultural, and political domains about which they a ect agnosticism.